Photos of day

Date: a month ago   Category: Law

How in cages during the meetings do treat keeping of defendants in Russia and abroad?


Departing from this practice, the Supreme Court essentially acted. How in the Russian courts did cages and why the idea is not pleasant to get rid of them to bailiffs appear? Photo: the Supreme Court of Russia essentially supports by depositphotos.com cancellation of cages in halls of vessels, the chairman of VS Vyacheslav Lebedev told journalists. "Justice can be carried out without cages" — he noted. Earlier the prime minister Dmitry Medvedev charged to Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Ministry of Finance to handle an issue of the ban on use in halls of court sessions of protective cabins for suspects. Last fall the group of parliamentarians introduced the relevant bill to the State Duma, but the special-purpose committee of the lower house postponed an initiative, having asked to revise some provisions, in particular, to clear safety issues both the suspect, and participants of process. In the Russian courts the European Court of Human Rights made the first decision on cages in December, 2012 in the matter of "Svinarenko and Slyadnev against Russia". The ECHR considered that Russia violates the 3rd article of the Convention on human rights forbidding humiliating treatment of people. The representative of Russia parried that "the room in a cage is applied only for reasons of safety of participants of process and first of all defendants from revenge". Then there were also another matters, on each of which the European Court of Justice awarded considerable compensations. But practice continues and until now, the lawyer of Musayev and Partners bureau Nadezhda Yermolaeva says. Nadezhda Yermolaeva is a lawyer of Musayev and Partners bureau "Keep [in cages] the cases accused all millions which are considered. There is quite created European practice that in civilized society it is inadmissible to keep people in a cage in court as until as the court made the decision and it took legal effect, this person is innocent, just the same citizen, as well as all others. The second moment: if we speak about jury, concerning the person who contains in a cage, obviously there is a prejudice, that this person is guilty. It cannot be kept just like that in a cage, the average citizen thinks". In Russia cages appeared in the early nineties. At the same time neither in Italy, nor in other Europe, the countries of America, in half of the African states and even China defendants if they are escorted by, sit and stand behind the most usual table, a rack or department. But it is clear why such option is not pleasant to police officers, the lawyer Alkhas Abgadzhava says. Alkhas Abgadzhava is a lawyer "Police officers have a cheap salary and absolutely useless work — to protect a door in court and to keep order that, God forbid, nobody clicked the camera. First, this cage in general concerns police officers a little because the convoy which has no relation to police officers is responsible for convoy. And here it turns out: there will be no cages, and right there they will have a lot of instructions about that they are more attentive it was watched, and some responsibility. At cheap salaries

URL:


Today

just now

From next January all will be able to come and look for work in Germany who have a profession — from plumbers to road builders. Whether it is difficult to find work in Germany? And what "the Russian e...

just now

Last week Naval Forces of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps detained the British tanker. The crew of the vessel consists of 23 people, among them there are Russians. It occurred after Great Brita...

just now

Final part of the main franchize of Marvel studio officially became the most high grossing film in the history of cinema. For updating of a record "Avengers" needed about four months of a hire of the...

35 minutes ago

Five large credit institutions reported about for what sums it was succeeded to prevent plunders for the first half of the year. And the main threat proceeds not from hackers at all, and from bank cle...

2 hrs ago

Last month more than 11.5 thousand DDU on the residential real estate — 54% more were registered, than in May, and it is twice more, than in June of the 2018th. It is the Photo indicator, record durin...

2 hrs ago

The Russian Union of Travel Industry said that if an incident is not exhausted, then the extensive list of unfair hotels will be published. Nevertheless now Russians guess: whether it will manage to t...

2 hrs ago

As raw materials the Krasnodar kind of these insects is considered. It is unpretentious and easily the Photo breeds: depositphotos.com Scientists from the ITMO University work on creation of biologica...

4 hrs ago

Concrete charges are not known so far, the Embassy of the Russian Federation in Italy does not comment on a situation. The Wex exchange was called BTC-E Dmitry Vasilyev earlier. Photo: a screenshot of...